When does silence equal complicity?
Two recent incidents lead me to pose this question. I do not intend it to be rhetorical or merely a catchy introduction to a blog post. I need some advice, so that when I face a similar situation in the future I will be better prepared to respond.
1. I was volunteering at a local food pantry that serves hundreds of needy families in the community, when I overheard a racially-biased comment about an Asian-American client. The speaker presumably believed that she was out of earshot of anyone but her friend, who laughed appreciatively at her joke.
I whipped my head from side to side—in what I like to think of as my “Moses Moment”—to see if anyone else was present and heard the remark. And, like Moses, I “saw that there was no one.” (Exodus 2:12) Unlike Moses, I did not react by smiting the speaker. The two friends breezed past me toward the walk-in refrigerator. I was invisible.
I did nothing. I said nothing. I acted as if I’d heard nothing.
2. Less than a week later, still ashamed of my silence, I was standing at the cash register of a local family-owned business that I frequent when the cashier made a racially-biased comment, laughing at her own joke as she swiped my credit card.
This time I reacted more swiftly than Moses. Like Moses, I reacted with indignation and (verbal) violence; though I suspect that my sarcasm might have gone unnoticed by the cashier, who handed me the purchase along with a bland “have a nice day.” I am certain that mine was the inappropriate response, an impulsive unleashing of pent-up frustration and remorse at my having been a bystander during the previous incident.
Months later, I still feel guilty that I was complicit, through my silence and through my speech, in a crime.
I am nonplussed by the ease with which these women—who may be otherwise polite, generous and kind—spoke such ugly words. I am concerned that they included or ignored me because they saw me not as “other” and assumed me to be like-minded. I am troubled that my silence sealed this judgment as true.
I am also stymied about how to respond in the future, when my character will, no doubt, be tested again. The one thing I know for sure is that I will only be able to subdue my demons—frustration and remorse—if I am prepared for the confrontation.
This is a small representation of the high-quality writings you’ll find in every issue of TIFERET.
We receive no outside funding and rely on digital issues, workshop fees, and donations to publish. If you enjoy our journal’s verbal and visual offerings, we hope you’ll consider supporting us in one of these ways.Click Here to Purchase Digital Issues